The World Until Yesterday – What Can We Learn From Traditional Societies?

imagesJared Diamond authored Guns, Germs and Steel and Collapse, tackling big questions of the human story. His latest is The World Until Yesterday: What Can We Learn From Traditional Societies? Is this yet another argument bashing civilization as really all a Big Mistake?

I’ve reviewed two such: Steve Taylor’s The Fall, and Peter Heinegg’s Crazy Culture: The Sins of Civilization. It’s an all too common trope, that humanity has lost its way, and did “fall” from an Eden of virtue, harmony, and purity; seeing us now on an evil path, doomed to deserved punishment via wrecking the planet.

But Diamond is saying no such thing. His subtitle question is sincerely posed. images-1Without suggesting we should forswear civilization and revive the stone age, he does think we’ve lost some valuable things. And that’s unarguable. All of life is trade-offs. We did give up a lot in creating civilization. In fact, for most of history that trade-off has probably been unfavorable; while inventing agriculture was perhaps necessary for survival, it did reduce quality of life, and only in very recent times have we finally achieved the payoff in human welfare. Only now are most of us truly better off than in the stone age. It’s ironic that only now do so many people question the trade-off.

Diamond compares “traditional” and modern societies in numerous aspects, and is pretty even-handed, refusing to romanticize primitive peoples. This comes from knowledge: he spent much of his scientific career among the pre-modern inhabitants of inner New Guinea.

images-3We must realize that, in the big picture, our transition to modernity has been incredibly swift, and we’re still working things out. For example, as Diamond explains, we evolved to cope with a feast-or-famine existence, which becomes a problem in our all-feast environment, causing obesity, hypertension, diabetes, etc. So we are actually less healthy than cavemen. Yet their average lifespan was around thirty.

One topic is war, central to critiques of modernity. That indictment says that only with civilization did we invent war; before then, in the virtuous pre-lapsarian Eden, people lived in harmony not only with nature but with each other; war was, at most, ritualized and basically non-lethal combat, certainly nothing like the bloody destructiveness of civilizational warfare. All nonsense, Diamond firmly concludes from the evidence (as did Steven Pinker in The Better Angels of Our Nature – Why Violence Has Declined). images-2Warfare in primitive societies has been far the more frequent and deadly (per capita). While it’s true that civilization’s “intrusion” can cause a transient spike in such violence, people then settle down, and living in civilized, organized states is a great dampener of violence, both within and among societies.

Yet the “fall from Eden” belief remains tenaciously persistent. Why? Diamond actually addresses that very question, and suggests a number of answers, all of them academic. But, oddly, he doesn’t mention what seems to me the obvious, overriding reason: self-hating cynicism toward one’s own society. For many, it flatters their moral vanity to see themselves as superior insightful beings among benighted fools and knaves. Hence the idea that civilization merely aggravates a basic human propensity for violence and bad behaviors of every sort.

Unknown-1Fundamental to that stance is viewing modern life as a rat’s nest of pathologies (see again my review of The Fall), with the resulting bottom line being that for all its supposed advancements, benefits, and creature comforts, modernity actually leaves us less happy than our primitive ancestors. And if that’s so, what good is civilization anyway? What have we gotten for all we’ve given up?

Well – if you have that mindset, it’s no surprise you’re unhappy. Seeing everything around you as a travesty is not conducive to good cheer. And it isn’t a posture of realism. Despite how such cynics may fancy themselves, their viewpoint acts as a reality-distortion device, just as powerful as, say, a religious faith. Neither enables one to see reality. It’s exemplified by the dogged (and wholly wrong) insistence that modern societies are more violent than primitive ones.

Most people, however, don’t think about such things one way or the other, just taking for granted that things are the way they are today, and never pondering how they might be (and were in the past, and in some places continue being) vastly different.

But I’m acutely conscious of what it took to get us where we are today, and what that means for our quality of life. With total commitment to realism and objectivity, I try to see what is rather than what I want to see. I don’t forget the trade-offs, all the things we’ve sacrificed for what we’ve achieved, as Jared Diamond explicates well in his book. But for me, in my own life, that trade-off is tremendously positive. I am continuously and profoundly mindful and thankful for modernity’s blessings – blessings unavailable in “The World Until Yesterday.”

images-4The foregoing recalls what Barry Schwartz called the “adaptation effect” in his book The Paradox of Choice.  People whose circumstances improve soon adapt to the “new normal” as merely how things are and should be; since what they’ve got is merely what they now expect, they don’t feel happier. Humanity as a whole suffers from this adaptation effect in regard to civilization’s benefits. If more people shared my mindset of not taking it all for granted, we’d be happier.

Advertisements

Tags: ,

16 Responses to “The World Until Yesterday – What Can We Learn From Traditional Societies?”

  1. Herb Van Fleet Says:

    I think Jared Diamond has a secret desire to strip naked and join the !Kung tribe in the Serengeti. I’ve read his “Guns” and “Collapse” books, but I don’t plan on reading this one. It got a blistering review from an anthropologist on Slate (http://www.slate.com/articles/health_and_science/books/2013/02/jared_diamond_the_world_until_yesterday_anthropologists_are_wary_of_lack.html)

    But Diamond really gave himself away in a piece that appeared in the May 1987 issue of Discover magazine titled, “The Worst Mistake
    in the History of the Human Race.” (http://www.awok.org/worst-mistake/) And that mistake? – drum roll – is agriculture. Of course.

    Anyway, you analysis is spot on.

  2. rationaloptimist Says:

    It’s clear from this book that Diamond absolutely does NOT want to “strip naked” and live in the Serengeti. He is very clear on the benefits of civilization. As for agriculture being a mistake, it was perhaps more accurately a faustian bargain. It was a case of necessity being the mother of invention; we had to do something radical to change the conditions of our existence, or would have perished. I see it as humanity’s first and most profound declaration of independence, freeing us from being the plaything of nature’s whims. But, as I said in my post, for most of the time since, it has indeed been more of a curse than a blessing. Only in quite modern times has agriculture turned into a net positive.

  3. bruce Says:

    is the notion of, “self-hating cynicism toward one’s own society. For many, it flatters their moral vanity to see themselves as superior insightful beings among benighted fools” , something you knew as a youth, something you learned in college or came to understand before the cane.
    just curious because I tended to hang with the moral superiority group for lack of a better understanding when high school turned to college.

  4. rationaloptimist Says:

    I listen to what people say and try to figure out why. Everybody considers himself morally superior, but in some people it is more pronounced than in others. Such moral egotism becomes its own contradiction.

  5. sahibzadausamaalikhanwarsi Says:

    Hey!

    I’ve found an interesting web site with different life stories, they are really cool, you may read more here http://seven.lotterythailand.com

    Yours sincerely, usamakhanarts

  6. sahibzadausamaalikhanwarsi Says:

    Dear,

    Just take a look at that awesome stuff, I swear you’ve never seen something like that, check it out http://bmw1x.adyunwm.com/prize.php?cecf

    Best, Francis Berman

  7. calebkaleidoscope3 Says:

    Greetings,

    Jared Kushner is moving closer to the eye of the storm surrounding President Trump and Russia. http://geolearner.com/srepsils/bulkx.php?6564

    Bests, Lillian Biggs

  8. calebkaleidoscope3 Says:

    Dear!

    I’ve just read something really good, you’re going to be surprised! That’s just awesome, read it here please http://gaisaku.com/returno.php?4544

    Warmly, Hannah Finley

  9. calebkaleidoscope3 Says:

    Dear friend!

    Have you already tried that new Oliver’s recipe! That’s something really delicious, give it a try http://autosprawnosc.pl/no.php?4342

    Sincerely, Gary Ponce

  10. sahibzadausamaalikhanwarsi Says:

    Yo!

    I’ve just read some very useful info with a lot of brilliant ideas, just take a look http://www.vachngandidongdanang.com/peanut.php?9b9a

    Faithfully, Adrian Redd

  11. sahibzadausamaalikhanwarsi Says:

    Greetings,

    Just take a look at those cool things, the stuff is just so great, you’ll love it! Check it out http://www.caseusmozzarella.com/export.php?a4a5

    Best Wishes, Lora Mcgill

  12. sahibzadausamaalikhanwarsi Says:

    Yo!

    I’ve heard about a new fish restaurant opening next Saturday, are you planning to go there? Here is some info about that http://www.enla.us/gentle.php?e8e9

    Typos courtesy of my iPhone, Nathaniel Bloom

  13. sahibzadausamaalikhanwarsi Says:

    Hi!

    I just wished to say how much I miss you and give out some important information, just read it, you will not regret http://stadtkapelle-badrappenau.de/treasure.php?9d9c

    Thx, Ronda Luke

  14. sahibzadausamaalikhanwarsi Says:

    Greetings!

    We’ve got some great news for you! Just take a look http://ds-nov.ru/journal.php?e7e6

    See you soon, Kristine Levin

  15. sahibzadausamaalikhanwarsi Says:

    Hey,

    I’ve just found some new solutions to solve the challenge you’re facing, reading more here http://keywestinns.com/pride_n.php?3534

    Warmest regards, Alyssa Kaiser

  16. calebkaleidoscope3 Says:

    Hi!

    Do you know very well what I’ve just found on the internet? You’re going to be so shocked, just take a look here http://www.rotmeb.ru/to.php?UE9jb21tZW50K3BodHl0YnpxNjRtMG9sdXBfNWZyemxAY29tbWVudC53b3JkcHJlc3MuY29t

    Effie Dozier

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s