Trump: no more Mr. Nice Guy

unknownNow he says the shackles are off him.

I’ve watched political debates for 56 years. But Sunday’s featured the most shocking and frightening thing I ever heard in one: Trump’s threat to jail his opponent.

We take for granted our free and open political competition. But if government can interfere with that, voting is meaningless. That happens in too many countries, like Russia, Cuba, Iran, China, Egypt, and now Turkey, where politically challenging those in power means jail. Dictators everywhere pervert laws and courts to lock up critics. Even in some ostensible democracies like Singapore and Malaysia, governments abuse judicial processes to persecute and neutralize political opponents. unknown-1We’ve just learned of South Africa’s well-respected finance minister being hit with corruption charges, an obvious political set-up (while President Zuma gets away with huge transgressions).

America was established to avoid just that kind of pernicious abuse, with a strong system of checks and balances, including an independent judiciary, and the First Amendment guaranteeing free expression. Our record is not spotless. The 1790s Alien and Sedition laws put a congressman behind bars for his anti-administration views; during the Civil War, some pro-slavery Northern politicians too were jailed; and Nixon tried to use the IRS to harass opponents. Yet those were exceptions that prove the rule. Throughout our history, the rule has been that you don’t use control over the levers of government power to beat on and intimidate political foes.

That, once more, has been a key underpinning of our democracy, because it gives opponents a fair chance of winning elections. And this is not even so much a consequence of our system and rules as it is a part of our culture. It’s our civic and political ethos; the way we’ve grown up to behave.

images-1The matters for which Trump threatens to jail Hillary Clinton have been fully investigated by the relevant federal authorities, and as explained by the (Republican) FBI Director, they determined that no criminal charges are appropriate. But even if that were not so, a candidate talking about jailing his opponent is a visceral, terrifying threat to the kind of country we are. Hearing it froze my blood.

This is not how America does politics.

Advertisements

Tags: , , ,

6 Responses to “Trump: no more Mr. Nice Guy”

  1. Roger Green Says:

    Even to stop Hillary, I cannot see the logic of anyone supporting DJT.

  2. Janice Russell Says:

    I’m finding the documents revealed by the recent Wiki-leaks troubling as well. It seems very likely to me that the DNC has manipulated this whole thing to make sure there is only one person to vote for in November. I’m voting for Gary Johnson, and ignoring all efforts to shame me for making that choice.

  3. rationaloptimist Says:

    I have made clear on this blog my voting for Johnson.

  4. Paul Landsberg Says:

    How many months has Donald Trump been saying this at his rallies?
    quick recap of ones I easily found
    early June, 2016 – San Jose
    July 2016 – RNC Convention (sale of Hillary for Prison t-shirts)
    August 2016 Austin, TX rally
    November 2015, Sarasota, FL

    You are surprised? Frightened?

    Trump has always been himself. Vile, petty, narcissistic, (insert the other 30 low attributes here) The level of repudiation at the polls in November matters — Electoral and popular vote.

  5. rationaloptimist Says:

    Much as it pains me to agree with you, Paul . . . no, I was not in fact surprised, I knew he’d been saying it, but to hear it said to her face in a national debate seemed to me to cross a line that had never been crossed before.

  6. Greg Says:

    Why is Trump the Republican nominee? The only conclusion I can come up with is he is an over-reaction to discouraged voters tired of ineffective governance by our existing representatives. He’s not the answer to our problems. He is the negative consequence of them.

    I would encourage conservative voters to repudiate the opposition-only philosophy to competing with liberals. Your representatives need to at least try to get something done on immigration, taxes, etc., etc., … even if some compromise is necessary. This will help prevent future “Trumps” from gaining such traction.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s