Inflation: The Big Misunderstanding

Inflation sours Americans about the economy — and President Biden. A January 14 Associated Press article by reporter Josh Boak examined this in depth. But failed to even mention a crucial point.

It does credit Biden with considerable success in curbing inflation — without sacrificing jobs — a neat trick, really, that many economists thought impossible. Boak notes that Covid-related supply chain gum-ups were a big cause of the inflation bout, and Biden tackled that forcefully, accounting for about 80% of the inflation abatement since 2022.

It has fallen nearly to the Federal Reserve’s 2% target, while we’ve added about 5 million jobs under Biden, with a 3.7% unemployment rate, around historic lows. Gas prices have come down a lot. Eggs were a focus of inflation ire, and their average price has fallen from a peak of $4.82 per dozen to just $2.51.

But, as Boak notes, it was $1.47 before Biden took office. And average prices across the economy certainly remain higher. Which brings me to the key point Boak omitted. The persistence of those higher prices makes people feel the problem isn’t solved. They want prices back down to their old levels.

Reflecting a fundamental misconception, confusing inflation rates and price levels. Reducing the inflation rate does not mean lower prices. It just means they rise more slowly. Reducing prices themselves is an unrealistic expectation.

And would actually be catastrophic. That’s deflation, which is an economy killer. Because it inhibits consumer spending — expecting prices to fall further, people postpone purchases. And deflation is much harder for economic policy to cure. Japan was a poster boy for this, suffering a long chronic deflation and consequently low growth, that its central bank struggled to overcome.

This in fact is why our Federal Reserve targets 2% inflation. Just minimal inflation, to guard against slipping into the slough of deflation. A careful balancing act.

Typically, Trump — with abysmal understanding of economics — is promising to bring prices down. “Gasoline will be back to $2,” or even lower, he says. In other words, he’s promising deflation. Yikes! But fortunately, it’s just bullshit, like everything coming from his mouth.

Boak’s article notes that gas did fall below $2 during Trump’s presidency. Early in 2020, when the pandemic crushed our economy, throwing millions out of work, and reducing demand for gas. (Trump’s idiotic mismanagement of the pandemic was responsible for its severity here compared to other countries.) Is that the halcyon time he’s promising to bring back — to make America great again??

3 Responses to “Inflation: The Big Misunderstanding”

  1. Anonymous Says:

    There’s also this, which doom-scrollable news reports on the U.S. economy often fail to mention: “Inflation eats into purchasing power, and many Americans have felt the bite of higher prices in their budgets in this recovery. But at the same time, higher wages and increased employment have outweighed the negative from inflation, and overall purchasing power has increased for most households.” (U.S. Treasury Dept., Dec. 14, 2023)

  2. Anonymous Says:

    Deflation in individual industries is fine. The phone I carry around in my pocket has technology that would have cost many times more a decade or two ago. The price of that technology has fallen drastically and that’s good, not catastrophic. In theory, the same could happen to eggs.

    That we did have inflation has everything to do with COVID-19 and, to a significant but lesser extent, to boycotts of Russian energy because of their aggression in Ukraine. Overall, Biden did a good job balancing these priorities, but eggs and many other commodities have suffered. (A universal basic income would help with this problem.)

    –Lee.

  3. Anonymous Says:

    This essay did not consider the impact of corporate profits. Profit taking accounts for the vast majority of the inflation post-2020. Corporations saw the opportunity to increase prices, and thus profits, in the haze caused by global supply snags and pandemic fears. Much like a rapacious convenience store owner raising the price of bottled water after a natural disaster.

    https://www.theguardian.com/business/2024/jan/19/us-inflation-caused-by-corporate-profits?CMP=Share_iOSApp_Other

    https://www.npr.org/2023/05/19/1177180972/economists-are-reconsidering-how-much-corporate-profits-drive-inflation

Leave a comment